Saturday, August 4, 2012

Olympians who use Strava

When watching the cycling time trials in the London 2012 Olympics I noticed some of the riders had Garmins on their bikes. My first thought was that these guys would go upload their rides to Strava right away - worried more about getting the KOM than the gold medal!

Notice the Garmin (at a funny angle) on Emma Pooley's TT bike
(July 31, 2012 - Source: Dan Kitwood/Getty Images Europe)
So I did a few searches within Strava to see which of these Olympians were, first of all, on Strava, and then whether or not they really uploaded their rides.

There are dozens of them who use Strava, which was no surprise. Like the rest of us, some use it more than others. Unfortunately, it doesn't appear that any uploaded their actual Olympics events.

However, I did find a few training rides just before the events:
Besides these four I found many others within Strava, most of them women for some reason. It's interesting to note that all of the Germans below and the one above (Teutenberg) live in California.
It's pretty fun to study their ride stats, though if I were a professional racer I don't think I'd be putting these up for the public. And if I did, I'd certainly leave out my best rides. So don't take them too seriously.

And whatever you do, don't do the side by side comparison unless you want to feel really weak and slow.

Tuesday, July 3, 2012

Pushing the Limits: How I Ran Myself to the Hospital

The Race
I recently pushed myself too far, too hard, and too fast - so much so that I landed myself in the hospital. I didn't really get hurt, but could have easily. I've analyzed the circumstances and the data I have from my GPS to get to the bottom of this and come up with some conclusions that might help others.

This was a run, not a ride, and was only 8km, in a hilly part of Singapore. Not a very competitive race - most were there just for fun - but still a race, with trophies for the first five finishers. I had bib number 100 a few days in advance, which told me there were at least 99 others in this. No matter the competition, I will always try my hardest to for the best finish. There's no such thing as a take-it-easy race.

To ensure I could really do it, two days in advance, I ran 8.6km at about 5:30 am. It was nice and cool (which I should have factored in) and I finished in 46 minutes (see it on Strava here) which demonstrated that I'd be OK come race day. And I forgot to add - I didn't drink any water during the race - only before and after.

Anyway I knew I'd be able to do this race. I cycle enough and don't think twice about doing 120km on my own on the weekends, home before 11am to go swimming with my kids. What's 8km on foot?

During that early-morning training run I had my heart rate monitor on, and to my surprise it rose to 175 - the highest I had ever seen it. I thought (prophesied?) to myself, "If I hit 176 I will collapse." In fact I was amazed I had never seen such a high figure while cycling, and only then began to realise how different cycling and running really are.

I even appealed to the wise of Facebook about such a heart rate anomaly 
         
So Saturday morning, before the race, I drank a few glasses of water and set off, heart rate monitor on and Garmin in hand. My pace was good and I was in the top four for the first few kilometers, until I passed one, then another, and was in second place.

As I passed the few workers along the course they yelled things like, "Keep going, you're second!!" while other runners, still coming the other direction in the loop clapped and cheered for me. Running is hard for me, and not fun. Agony, really, but their encouragement kept me going and gave me some hope.

The course was poorly marked with lazy attendants at only some of the junctions leaving us to guess as to where to go. Once I went straight up a steep hill, through a group of tourists from China on a narrow sidewalk, and back down. Obviously this was wrong way, but I made it back down and maintained my position, though losing energy and time.

Amazingly even at the halfway point there was no water. When I cycle I carry a lot of water (probably not enough though). I can hold as much as 2 litres, which can last me 120km of road or 30km of off-road. But when running, almost nobody carries water. Bad idea.

It was not the hottest time of day, though the sun was out. I was drenched in sweat and humidity was high, as it always is in Singapore. So I was hurting for some water. And it was getting hotter. But in the back of my mind, I was thinking, "This is a short race, only 8km, and I'm almost done. I'll keep pushing on! I'm in the front and I want a trophy!"

Then somewhere around km 5 there was a water stand set up with small plastic glasses. I grabbed one, most of it spilled, and I drank the remaining hundred ml or so. At least in Malaysia in the mountain bike jamborees they offer 500ml bottles of water, already opened, that won't spill as easily as a cup, so you don't have to stop to drink them. They always have bananas, too, which are full of electrolytes.

Around that point I passed friends coming back the other direction in this loop, including my wife, whom I didn't even say hi to. At that point I realized I must have been pushing it pretty hard.

The Garmin agreed - I had been watching my heart rate, which had by this time exceeded 180. By the traditional formula my max was 182. I saw it hit 183 and was amazed. Amazed and excited and exhausted and encouraged all at once.

The run went over Henderson Waves and the Forest Walk. Henderson Wave is said to be the highest pedestrian bridge in Singapore (36m); Forest Walk is an elevated steel walkway over the jungle. Both were fun to run on - a change from the boring and dangerous roads.

Forest Walk
Photo credit: Soonhuat95
Making my way downhill along the Forest Walk, towards about km 7 or so, I suddenly lost my balance. I grabbed the steel railing, incredulous that I couldn't stand up. Another runner, not in this race, came to my help. He told me to sit down, but I refused. I was worried the guy behind me would pass me and I'd lose my position. I stumbled along, like I was extremely drunk, gripping the rail, with this fellow jogger telling me to take it easy. I kept trying to get up and run, but kept falling back down.

I couldn't see anything around me. Only my hands out in front of me. I don't recall him or his face. I don't know if anybody passed me. I was quickly losing it.

In the back of my mind was the slogan from RoadID, the bracelet for runners and cyclists that lists their name, next of kin, pertinent medical info and more. Ironically, I lost mine in a crash, one of the high-speed, super-muddy, downhill, Malaysian variant. That slogan? "Never give up" Bad advice.

The next thing I knew I was on a stretcher.

I felt extremely weak. I couldn't open my eyes or move. It took some effort to talk. One voice among all stood out. There must have been anywhere from 5 to 10 people there helping me, and this guy was a real leader. He was telling the others what to do, how to carry the stretcher, when to pick it up, put it down, to give me water, and more. He had the charisma, confidence, and leadership I needed.

He told me he's a rugby player, that he was recently in Vietnam for a match, that he saw a picture of John Wayne being depicted as a POW, and other things to get my mind off my condition. He told me about a team in the Bay Area (B.A.) whose chant prior to each game was, "I pity the fool!" In general he made me feel great. I never saw his face or got his name but he truly kept my spirit up when I needed it.

I thought he might be an experienced soldier; in fact more like a seasoned officer. When picking up the stretcher he'd count, "3, 2, 1, 0" and on "0" they'd lift. He had command of the situation. Something everybody knew was needed but nobody else knew how to do.

Somebody must have come along with some water, because I remember drinking some (I have no idea where they got it or how they got the water down to the Forest Walk - same with the stretcher!) Then for some other reason, they put me down, maybe to rest. I said, "Does somebody have a phone? I've got to call Earl!"

And I rolled out of the stretcher and put my face directly on the steel grill which comprised the floor, and proceeded to upchuck all that water and probably my breakfast (funnily enough, my breakfast was the cereal called "Fitnesse"!) It was convenient that my vomit could so easily pass through the floor and into the jungle canopy.

That's a kind of obvious metaphor isn't it? Me vomiting up all my Fitnesse?

Not long after that they said a medic had arrived. I assumed it was somebody associated with the run, but I learned later it was a team of real medics from an ambulance. They wanted to put me on their stretcher, but the Rugby Guy wisely told them that the ride would be too bumpy for me since their stretcher was on small wheels and we were on the rough steel grill surface.

The medic started asking me semi-comprehensible questions, including my name and other stuff. Too bad I had lost my RoadID. I demanded to have the Rugby Guy back in control, but wisely and respectfully, he deferred to the professionals.

I really don't know how long this whole thing took - maybe half an hour - but eventually the Rugby Guy said we were almost at the bottom. I finally managed to open my eyes and that's when I noticed a serious looking stretcher and the back of an ambulance. This was too much for me. I couldn't accept the fact that I really needed medical treatment. Not me.

Two Hours of Hell
Nope I'm not going in any ambulance. I never have been and never will. It's pathetic enough that I didn't finish this short race. I really look like a wimp now. I've never not finished a race. I guess I can get up and I'll be fine. I'll just drive home. My car's only about 50m away in the Hort Park carpark. But no ambulance.

Heart rate analysis - The orange arrow is where I shut down (HR at 186).
The purple arrow is where I was put into the ambulance (HR jumped from 143 to 161).
Anxiously, I proclaimed, "I'm OK! I am! But really I'm not. But if I know I'm not, then I am, and that makes me sane! But if I am right then I know I'm not OK."

It was reassuring to be able to admit that I knew I was not OK. It convinced me that I wasn't crazy, because I could objectively see that I was in bad shape. Yet I equated being sane with being physically ready to get up and walk away. I had totally lost it.

I went into a fatal loop of flawed logic and escalating delirium. I spiralled into a psychological abyss of erroneous conjectures and terrifying assumptions.

They loaded me into the ambulance, and my senseless babbling only increased. I remember thinking to myself, "I must forget this. I will be haunted for life. Nobody will believe me that I was actually sane enough to see that I wasn't OK, and that I was really OK. I am in serious trouble. They'll think I'm insane but I know I'm sane because I know I'm not OK. There is no escape."

Then I ordered the paramedic, "Document this! Send it in to the medical journals! You have to write all of this down!"

Naturally, they just ignored me.

The sheer horror of this is nothing I could ever faithfully recount. In my garbled-up brain, at the time, I was doomed and my hellish-like fate had been sealed. There was no escape, ever. I couldn't be a viable parent or husband anymore. That's really what I believed.

To get a reality check, I asked my wife, who was in the ambulance to talk to me. I needed reassurance that she was there and that she cared; I needed a barometer from her as to my condition. Was she freaking out or cool?

Thankfully, she responded, and was anxious but not out-of-control.

I felt like Jacob Singer in Jacob's Ladder.
I addition to my Jacob's Ladder-like nightmare, I was faced with the anxiety of going to a hospital. And with the Rugby Guy gone, there was no real leader to keep me from totally losing my marbles. It was a bit late for that though.

I was shocked and stunned. I couldn't discern how or why I reached the indescribable state I was in.

As I understand, from my psychology degree, the neurotransmitters in your brain need electrolytes (potassium, sodium, magnesium, calcium and I think others) between them in order to both send a signal across a synapse and to prevent signals from continuing to be sent. These signals, I believe, can be between nerves (your brain is pure nerves) or from a nerve to a cell (like a muscle cell).

So when you don't have any electrolytes, the 'wires' get mixed up or stop altogether both in your brain and to your muscles. Either they don't fire or maybe they do but they don't stop! In other words you go bat-shit crazy and you collapse.

Soon I found myself on a bed in the emergency room of some hospital; I had no idea which. I was surrounded by doctors and nurses, trying to figure out what was wrong with me. I was mad. I was confused. I was incredulous. I was delirious. At one point I even said, "This is fun!" I was loco.

"Are you allergic to any medicines?" a doctor or nurse asked.
"How would I know, I haven't tried them all," I sarcastically replied.

"Can you move your arm over?" another attempted.
"Yes," I said, but then didn't move my arm.

"We're going to put a needle in you, OK?" a doctor asked.
"No, I really have a phobia of needles, you can't do it," I insisted.
"But we need to check your blood to see what's wrong with you."
"What's wrong with me, I'm freaking dehydrated, can't you tell!"
"We also need to put this solution in you to give you electrolytes," she said.
I answered, "No needles! Go buy some Gatorade!"

Recovery
She eventually talked me into it, and they put one in each arm. I felt much better almost instantly. It was almost cathartic how the anxiety and horror dissipated into a laughable illusion. My confusion started to clear. I became polite. I apologized to the nurses and doctors. I became rational. My sanity returned.

Not long after that they took me to get a CAT scan to make sure I didn't have a stroke or any brain damage.

Here's how my brain looked turned to oatmeal
I kind of look like Homer Simpson here. Felt like him too.

Doctor: "This guy's here for some x-rays and stuff. Why don't you just do one of his chest for fun?"
Good thing I have insurance.
The hospital must have been really broke to want to x-ray my knee just because it had a scratch on it.
Nobody could have really thought it was broken.
This is the kind of scratch I get regularly when I mountain bike.
To treat it, they covered it in tetracycline, layers and layers of gauze, and a ton of adhesive waterproof covers.
I ripped all that crap off as soon as I got home.
They also X-rayed my chest (no idea why) and my knee, which had a tiny cut on it. (The cut is cool - it is an imprint of the metal grate we jogged on.) Of course nothing was broken.

My kids were happy to visit me in the hospital
After a few hours, I was taken to my room. There was really nothing to do - my wife brought me a few books and my iPad, and of course my kids visited. Some friends and colleagues visited, which was cool. But more than anything I just needed rest. Lots and lots of rest.

I was there just over 48 hours. Over that period they took my blood and did an ECG every 8 hours, gave me a tetanus shot, and took my blood pressure about once every 30 seconds it seemed.

They put layers and layers of gauze on my knee scrape, in addition to tetracycline, and about a half-dozen clear adhesive plastic water-proofing films. Seriously, the bandages were far more uncomfortable than the cut.
Fall precaution? What in the world could have ever given them that preposterous idea?
I had (still have) a giant bump on my head which everybody ignored. I had a headache for three days. And Paracetamol is useless to me.

Heart Rate
I've heard the saying that the only heart rate you need to ever worry about is one that's zero. If this is true, it means you won't hurt yourself by maxing it out. Anybody who uses a heart rate monitor probably has a good idea of what their maximum heart rate is. The common formula is HR = 220 minus your age.

But this so-called formula is only a rough gauge. It was devised in the '70s by a guy named Dr. Haskell and was based on 10 previously-published studies. The subjects in those studies were not representative of the population, and the estimate wasn't meant to be taken too seriously. But it was convenient and it came at a time when athletes and coaches wanted a figure to put to training levels, and technology was coming out that could incorporate these formulae, like treadmills and heart rate monitors. (Source: NYT article)

So it stuck, and we all seem to use it: 220 minus your age.

Also, we're all different - a friend of mine's heart rate easily hits 190 when he cycles but never goes above 170 when he runs. And he's 41. I, on the other hand, at 38, hit a max of 167 cycling but was recently able to reach 186 running. It doesn't add up. Your real maximum may vary by up to 20 beats per minute from Haskell's casual formula.

So not accurately knowing your maximum may result in you training in the wrong zones, either too high or too low, and not getting the most out of yourself, or overdoing it. And what I find amazing is that my maximum on my bike seems to be different than the maximum when I run. Perhaps my maximum when I swim is different too?

If the saying is true, and that you can't explode your heart from excess exercise, there must be other things that will give out first. For me, it's hydration and nutrition.

Conclusion
As with many emergency or unusual situations, a variety of conditions must be present simultaneously for them to occur. Some of these may be perfectly normal, but in combination, they can be deadly. Any one of these factors on their own wouldn't have had the same result. I'll do my best to list them out below.

1. I am not a trained runner and do not have the experience or physical capacity to achieve what I thought I could. My cycling fitness didn't transfer over to running as easily as I thought it would have. I overestimated myself.

2. I did not drink enough water beforehand or during the race. I had two glasses of water right before the run, and a fraction of one of the small glasses at the second water stop. The first one wasn't even set up by the time I arrived.

3. I did not have enough electrolytes. This would have been fine had I not run so hard. After all, probably the majority of the participants didn't pay any attention to their electrolyte levels, yet they finished.

3.5. And my last one, more like an excuse or a complaint, is the wrong turn I took.

The race crew were not on their toes. They didn't see our urgent need to know which way to go! We don't want to slow down and ask directions; we need to know at least 20-30m in advance so we can plan our line and where we run. One of them was lying on a bench playing on her phone. Another told me to go left when there were two lefts: a paved sidewalk that went into the jungle and a road. I didn't know which to take.

But the worst one was at the top of Mt. Faber where there's a very sharp bend, maybe 120 degrees, which leads back down or up even higher to some kind of monument. The guy just said "go right" but didn't say where, and by the time I had to make the choice he was out of sight.

I decided to err on the safe (hard) side and go uphill, as I remembered they said "to the top" in the pre-race briefing, but all I found was elderly China tourists. I found a stairway down the other side which led me back to the road, but I lost a considerable amount of time and exertion on that one.

I suppose I could have finished just fine had any of one of the first three been resolved. I bet even if I would have overestimated myself, but I had the water, I would have been fine. But believe me, I'll make sure I fulfil at least two out of the three from now on. I think it's fine to overestimate yourself, but now I know you need the proper safety net in place.

I will go back to that course, I will conquer it, and I will do it in a respectable time. It should not be hard given what I have learned.

But most important of all, I have to give all my thanks to the Rugby Guy. I must thank him for:
  1. Having the selflessness to sacrifice his race finish and position for my health
  2. Having the leadership to direct others in a time of confusion
  3. Having the charisma to keep my morale up and get my mind of my pain
I'm trying to track him down and when I do, I'm taking him out for beer. Rugby Guys like beer right?

And if he wants to push himself too hard on the beer, no problem, I've got his back like a stretcher.

---------------------------------

Update
A few days after posting this entry I tracked down the Rugby Guy. His name is Ian, and he's a lawyer. I called him and thanked him for all he had done. Additionally, I got his home address. I ordered a dozen local craft beers to be delivered to his house that night, in appreciation for all he had done. Luckily, he is someone who can appreciate good microbrews.

We finally meet
Then a week after that we finally met up. This was the first time I had seen him, though I felt like I knew him. Over a few more beers, he explained to me how he got the stretcher to me (the organisers had one, and they yelled to the one of the marshals who got it), and a few other missing memories.

Throughout this experience, I learned a lot about my body and my mind, and it has only made me stronger and more prepared for the next race.

Ride hard or ride home.

Friday, April 6, 2012

Choosing a GPS Device for Strava: Mobile Phone or GPS?

I'm going to assume you know what Strava is - the website that times and maps your rides (or runs) and then compares them with others who have done the same ride or part of ride. You record the ride using a GPS device, and when finished, upload it to the Strava site and can then see how fast you were compared to others.
A screen capture of the Strava interface

I have been using Strva now for about nine months, starting with an iPhone. I always carry my phone with me on rides in case I get injured badly enough that I need to call for help or for other emergencies, so this is convenient.

With a mobile device (iOS or Android) you must download the Strava app, and then start it when you begin your ride. When you finish, click "end ride" and the data automatically upload to the Strava site. This is alwasy very easy for me, except about 2-3 times when the app has failed to record my rides. Strava has since rewritten the app and I don't think these bugs exist any more.

In November I bought a Garmin GPS from a neighbor who rides and who recently bought a newer Garmin. It came with the heart rate monitor and cadence sensor. I installed the cadence sensor on my road bike, and use the heart rate monitor on both road and off-road rides.

To use the Garmin is a bit more complex - first you have to ensure you have recieved a satellite signal, which I find can be difficult if you are moving or if the sky is very cloudy. (The iPhone gets a signal immediately via its 3G connection). Then, you have to press "Start/Stop" when you begin the ride and when you end.

The next step is to connect the Garmin to your computer with the USB cable (which also doubles as a charger). Now forget about the Garmin Connect site. Go to Strava.com, download some applet or driver from the site (which I had trouble doing in Chrome on a PC but no issues with in Chrome on a Mac), and the site will detect your Garmin.

Finally, you need to click on "Upload Activity" and subsequently select the events (rides) it finds in your Garmin using checkboxes, and hit "Upload". You can then name the ride, crop it, specify which bike you were on, and add comments or notes about it ("Saw pink pangolin" "Kristan made me sniff his gloves").

It will include any heart rate and cadence data that your mobile phone can't record.

So which is better? Originally I thought the Garmin would be superior for Strava, but eventually I realized the iPhone has its distinct advantages. Here are the pros and cons I see in each:

Mobile
Pros
  • No need to buy a new device if you already have an iPhone or Android
  • Upload happens instantly after the ride - no need to connect to your computer. Great when you ride fast in the morning and then rush off to work and don't have time to upload it manually.
  • Can record speed, distance, and location even underground, in carparks, under heavy clouds or other places a GPS-only device cannot. This is due to its 3G connection. This is a major bonus for me.
  • The app interface lets you see your speeds, history, records, and more - it even synchs with rides you did on your Garmin meaning it'll show your full Strava history
Cons
  • Doesn't show real-time data - meaning during a ride distance or speed at any given moment will be wrong. Major drawback
  • Doesn't record heart rate or cadence
  • The elevation it records is amusingly innacurate - sometimes speeds are too - but the mapping and distance are accurate
  • Drains your battery but has never killed mine - can easily handle 5-6 hours of recording so not an issue unless you'll be riding longer than that
GPS (Garmin)
Pros
  • Real-time monitoring - this is invaluable to me, especially when I'm racing
  • Has many other awesome features that could help you be a faster or more efficeint rider like averages (speed, cadence, heart rate), total distance traveled, sunrise and sunset, tons of data
  • Specific to Strava, the heart rate and cadence are important in calculating the Strava Sufferscore, an estimation of how much pain you endured which considers heart rate level, distance, time, and more.
  • Depending on the model you have you can see where you are on a map. Even some of the older Garmins that don't support maps can still help in navigation by at least showing your compass heading and a trail of where you have been.
  • Water, mud, and crashproff to some degree
Cons
  • They're kind of expensive once you buy the heart rate monitor and cadence sensor
  • If you leave it plugged into your computer to charge it, then shut off your computer, its battery may simply run down without you knowing it - a big bummer when your ride starts (that's when you use the iPhone as backup)
  • Spotty satellite reception at times, and slow to pick it up (up to 5 minutes)
If I had to choose one I'd still go for the Garmin, only for the invaluable race and training data I get from the heart rate monitor and cadence sensor.

Wednesday, March 21, 2012

Showers Pass VelEau 42 Hydration System

If you've consumed as many 40ozers as I have you'll know that 40oz is 1.18 litres (it says so on the labels). So a hydration system that holds 42 ounces will be around 1.2 litres of malt liquor, or eau as our Showers Pass friends must call water.

At 1.2 litres I think I could go 30-40km hard in our high humidity under the shade of the jungle. Anything longer and I may need a bit more. My smallest CamelBak holds 1.5 and I hardly ever finish it, even on the hottest of our tropical days.

So when my mom brought me a VelEau 42 straight from the source (Portland, Oregon - where, incidentally they have a lot of good beer as well!) I knew it was about the right size for me.

If the name "VelEau 42" seems cryptic to you, it can mean nothing other than 'bike water 42' in French, 42 obviously being the capacity. Now if I could only figure out what "Showers Pass" means.

Image from the Showers Pass site. Note the tool pouch.
I have three bikes and I don't want to use this for road riding. I'm perfectly happy with my two conventional water bottles, and on the road bike obviously wouldn't carry a CamelBak.

But here in Singapore, it's hot and humid 365 days a year, and a CamelBak worsens that. Any solution that can remove that sweaty hump from my back is welcome, and when I first saw this online I knew I wanted to try one.

So this would be best on one of the mountain bikes - how about the Giant Reign 1, a 6-inch all-mountain?

Installation was super simple and obvious - the strong plastic strap ratchets on through the saddle rails. It is secure as could be, and ought to fit on any bike. I saw some reviews online - no, not reviews - speculation - that it must wobble around, but I can clearly see that it won't.

The tube is secured to the stem/steerer with thin nylon strings on spring-loaded reels which hold it there with little magnets.

Without a pack I need a way to store my tools, tube(s), pump, phone and other junk I keep with me on every ride. The pouch only really has space for one fat MTB tube (way bigger than a little road tube), a larger multi-tool, and my wide Park Tools tire levers.

Phone, pliers, pump and other stuff will have to go somewhere else, or stay home. I do like to carry my phone for emergencies, especially when I ride across the border to our own little Tijuana (Johor Bahru, Malaysia). But I could do it roadie style and put it in my jersey pocket...which then means I have to wear a cycling jersey on my all-mountain MTB...

The pump could be attached to the frame using the bracket it came with, but that doesn't look so great. Or, I could stick to the road style mentioned above and chuck it in my jersey pocket.

Anyway, I have yet to try this, but will soon (race coming up this weekend in Malaysia) and I will post a follow-up with photos.

Time will tell if I stick with this or not.

---------

First impression 

Installed and ready for the trail


I like the hose in the middle of the bar by the stem where I can see it. Sometimes with my CamelBak I can't quite find the hose - it can flip around and get lost.

The flow of water was maybe a tiny bit weaker than any of my CamelBaks, but not so weak that I had to really suck. The valve is just like one of my CamelBak's valve - a simple piece of rubber without any lock like some have (which my High Sierra has but I never use).

The midde magnet


Upon releasing the hose from your mouth, the parachute cord reels it back to the magnet, hitting it about half the time. If I actually cut my hose down it would hit every time. Now the hose is too long but I'm just going to test it like this before trimming it.

The middle magnet on the top tube seemed to connect every time. The magnet and reel on the seat post always latched.

I routed the hose through the saddle as seen on the Showers Pass site - this is a neater and cleaner installation. It runs pretty close to the reservoir but the reservoir is so secure and stable there's no risk of pinching the tube.

I'm a pretty aggressive rider and tend to like to drop behind the saddle quite a lot. Surprisingly the VelEau didn't get in my way - I was able to slide behind it like I was riding down some steep terrain no problems. Let me give it a real ride and see for sure.

I didn't notice the weight (though I didn't fill it all the way with water). If anything I did notice the lack of weight on my back, so that will more than make up for any handling difference!

Some of the nice design features I observed:
  1. The surface of the bottom of it is a rubbery material that will be easily cleaned after picking up the inevitable mud and crud (as opposed to the nylon everywhere else)
  2. There are six small loops on the bottom of it and six on top which could be used to attach anything - pump, small pack, fender, bottle of beer
  3. Reflective tubing around the top of it, as well as a large reflective label that could double as a hook to attach a light
  4. The connection to the seat post is simple and elegant: a rubber block that will fit snugly to any post, secured by velcro. In fact it's strong enough to hold the whole thing on its own - I tested it.
Note the black block between the seat post and the hard plastic tube routing

Obviously a lot of thought and development was put into this product. Again, the real test will be real riding.


---------

The Verdict


A race is the ultimate test for not only the rider and the bike but the supporting equipment. My first trail test of thie VelEau 42 was in a race of about 450 riders in Pasir Gudang, Johor, Malaysia. The course consisted of 45 km of fire roads, plantation roads, singletrack and some paved roads.

The first test was whether or not the bite valve would return home to its position on the stem easily. As per my parking lot test, it did about half the time, but would have more if I had trimmed the hose shorter. By returning home I mean each of the magnets connecting directly and immediately without any intervention on my part. This is good enough for me because I can trim the hose and because adjusting it is not an issue, not even in a race.

The second test, maybe the one I was most worried about, was how securely it connects to the bike. And boy did I ever test this! At the bottom of a hill was a muddy depression which I hit squarely and hard. My front wheel sank 1/3 and immediately froze. This catapulted me spectacularly into the air, over the bar, the bike acting as a lever with the VelEau at the end of it.

Unbeknownst to me, my Garmin embedded itself into the mud (amid hundreds of other racers - this was at the start) but the Showers Pass wasn't phased. It didn't rotate left or right, the hose didn't go anywhere, and everything was secure. (Incidentally, I had to backtrack later when I realized I had lost my GPS. The force of the fall was so great that it completely annihilated the hard plastic bracket the Garmin uses to connect to my bar.)

Throughout the rest of the race, I had no issues. I felt liberated by not having to carry a pack or bottles in my jersey pocket.

The thing got entirely encrusted in mud but washed clean easily.

Overall, I'm very happy with it and I will keep using it.

Singlespeed and Knee Pain

After a few months of hard singlespeed riding, during a 120km road ride, I experienced a sharp pain in my right knee. It felt like a red hot needle was being poked through it, right along the joint. The pain was all the way through, laterally, equal on both the inside and outside.

The pain came when I pedalled hard or mashed with that leg. At a fast and light spin it was back to normal - standing up or going in a bigger gear intensified the pain.

After a number of visits to a physiotherapist and a doctor, I determined the pain is a result of:


  1. An injury I had to this knee 11 years before
  2. Overuse from mashing too hard, mostly on my singlespeed (at a high ratio too!)
  3. Low cadence (point 2) even on a road bike (cadence around 75)
  4. The daily wear and tear of even road riding


The physiotherapist gave me exercised to do but couldn't really help. He had me take videos of myself on my bike to check my position, and he said it was ok.

I had a more experienced friend re-fit me on my road bike and check my cleat position also - all ok (after I bought a shorter stem).

The doctor prescribed me some medicine that is designed to help regenerate the knee (and shoulder). They are Regenerix and Arthrex DX.

Since taking those I've had no problems, only some slight dull pain that I can live with. But I have had no problems during rides.

The moral of the story: If you ride singlespeed err on an easier gear. Don't overdo it like I did. Don't try for a harder gear thinking you'll get stronger, especially if you have ever had a knee injury before.


Friday, December 16, 2011

So I got the Homebrewed cogs in the mail awhile back - and they are every bit as beautiful as people say they are.

15, 16, 33

Nice and thick to prevent damaging your  cassette body

On the bike

Sunday, October 9, 2011

Homebrewed Components - Choosing a Chainring and Cog Combo

For my post on choosing a rear cog go here: choosing a cog

I'm in the market for a new cog and chainring for my singlespeed. Homebrewed Components seems to be a preferred designer and manufacturer of cogs and rings by many singlespeeders, and is mentioned quite a bit in the mtbr.com forums.

Dan Wilcox is the man behind Homebrewed. He explains how the business started:

After being a Machinist/Engineer for my whole working life, i decided to start up my own machine shop. Granted, doing it in the height of the economic recession was probably not the best of ideas, but i figured what does not kill me will only make me stronger. Also, i figured it would keep me from making a bunch of useless crap that has flooded the markets partially causing this predicament we’re in.
At first, i started making parts for other companies and building tooling for people i had worked for in the past. That was going OK, but it wasn't really what i wanted to do with my capabilities. Also, i take pride in what i do, and if I’m going to make something, i want my name on it, not someone else’s. 
Now here’s where i started thinking… what do i like to do the most? Well, that would be creating things and mountain biking. How can i put those 2 together? Well duh, make bike parts! At first it was just going to be a hobby to cure some boredom in between the normal work. I started making chain tensioners using part of a design that i had made a few years ago. The only modifications i did to it were basically a little material removal to lighten them up. I posted them up on a web forum and got some decent feedback along with a few orders.

Read the full post at the Homebrewed Components blog.

I'm currently running a 2:1 ratio, and feel I could do better with a fraction more, maybe 2.1:1 or 2.2:1. This will make my flats a bit faster and the hills harder. Coming from a 32 - 18, I was on a 1.78:1 ratio. So a jump up to 2:1 was 22 tenths.

Using this 22 tenths figure as a benchmark, I don't think I could handle another jump of 22 tenths considering the terrain where I live (it's not very hilly but the few hills we have would be very hard for me at 2.22:1 I think.

Let's take a look at the combinations Dan from Homebrewed offers. This is a grid between the aluminum chainrings he has which are compatible with 104 BCD (for Shimano) and his aluminum standard cogs.
Ratios between Homebrewed Al chainrings and Al cogs

The red cells are ratios I don't think I can handle. The greens are even less viable as they're even easier than what I'm running now. And the orange cells are what I'm on now.

So my best options are those in the white, above 2.0 and below 2.22. I think 2.21, 2.20, and 2.19 are probably just about the same or indistinguishable from 2.22, so I'll avoid those. I think 2.12 or 2.13 would be best.

Starting from the bottom of the chart, 2.12 at 36-17 is good, as it affords more chainwrap than the other options, but it doesn't leave me with many options if 2.12 is too hard or too easy - the neighboring cells are 2.0 and 2.25.

The next choice is 35-17 producing a ratio of 2.06, which probably isn't quite aggressive enough. 35-16 sounds just right, and if it is too hard, I can keep the 35 and easily move to a 17 cog.

The problem with 34-16, is I can only move down to a 2.0 if the 2.13 is too hard.

A 33 chainring give me almost exactly the same ratios as a 35, but being smaller would be a hair lighter - but I'd lose some chainwrap.

32-15 is the same as 34-16, including the neighboring options.

A 31 ring looks good, as I can get 2.21 with a 14 or if that's too hard, 2.07 with a 15.

I wonder just how critical chainwrap is. I suppose there's only one way to find out, and that's test it myself by buying a 31-14 and 15.

Last, I wonder why Homebrewed has so many other ratios that very few singlespeeders would ever want. I'd imagine the 31-24 combo would be far too slow to ride on the road and not practical unless you lived in a super hilly area.

-----

Update, 11 Oct, 11

As I was about to place my order, I noticed a note regarding the 31T chainring. It says:

This is enough for me to not order the 31, not knowing the extent to the modifications or why it may not fit.

Thus, I'll go with a 33 and a 15 and 16 for almost identical ratios to the 31 with a 14 and 15.